Tuesday, May 26, 2015
Fundraising, The Final Day!
You can still give to this blog to cover the costs and the chocolate which fuels my engines. Thanks to all who have contributed, mwah. And yes, the final day really should have been Friday but I charge nothing for late payments.
In other news, my humerus bone break is growing callus, the precursor to bone (though it looks like mold in the x-ray pics)*. It also hurts less, and physical therapy should begin this week. I'm recording all the monetary information for a participatory study in health care economics!
Knitting needles are excellent for scratching an itching-and-healing arm in an immobilizer, but hot weather doesn't help. Still, recovery is good, and I'm probably going to remain more ambidextrous.
That's my news. What are yours?
-----
*Looking at those x-rays made me laugh at the idea that humans are the crown of creation. Start with a poorly designed rickety framework and then cover it with meat? Worms are a better initial idea but they need hands and wheels. Birds are an even better idea, though once again they need hands.
Speed-Posting, 5/26/15: Tanith Lee, Women in Palmyra and Bruce Bartlett on Fox News
1. RIP Tanith Lee, the master of dark fantasy. She is one of the writers whose books people recommended to me and whom I read, to the extent the local library would allow, but no more. Now I regret the fuzzy idea I had of reading more of her some time later.
2. The Islamic State has taken over the cities of Ramadi in Iraq and Palmyra in Syria. Among all the horrors that are taking place it's worth noting that it took only about a day after the invasion of Palmyra for IS to start preaching in the mosques that all women must cover their faces or be flogged.
It's not that the orders are to be compared with the beheadings and kidnappings and the general butchering IS is so fond of, but note the central role the control of women has in their ideology. The orders of proper dress for women couldn't wait until the first round of killings were finished.
Needless to say, there's nothing about the covering of the face in the Koran; only about the covering of the bosom. But conservative extremist religion always centers on the control of women. And strict sex-segregation means that women cannot now get adequate health care inside the "caliphate" because male doctors can't treat women and there are too few female doctors and nurses.
3. Bruce Bartlett has written an article about the self-induced brain-washing (lefty view) or brain-cleansing (righty view) watching Fox News can cause. You can download the article here.
I read it. Bartlett gives statistics about the ignorance effect: In several categories Fox News watchers know less about political events than those who don't watch any news. But his piece is not original research, and I was left asking why there's a whole television channel for one party but not for the other party. Also what planet Fox's female commentators come from and whether looking like a Barbie doll is the first requirement. But obviousle men don't have to look like the boyfriend called Ken, or have tiger-eye makeup.
Watching Fox (which I did a few weeks ago) is initially hilarious. Then you start feeling you can't breathe, so you start analyzing what is removing the oxygen from the room. Is it the constant repetitions of the same news, most about the perfidy of Obama or complete fluff? Or is it the utter absence of news you see covered everywhere else? Or all the messages crawling across the screen? If you follow those you wouldn't be surprised to read that Democrats cause cancer.
On the other hand, Bartlett notes that Fox News may not ultimately help Republicans in elections, because it flames the anger of conservatives and moves them even further rightwards. Then those same conservatives vote for very extremist candidates in the primaries, and you get the tea-partiers.
It could be the case that we all live in similar ideological bubbles, could be. But I try to follow news from various outlets and from several countries, and the Fox world stands out as belonging to a different galaxy.
Monday, May 25, 2015
Memorial Day 2015
You might like the links in my post for Memorial Day 2013.
This year I'm blocked. To write about this day in depth requires grave-digging, deep explorations into the reasons for wars, the evaluation of the need for any particular one of them, the meaning of sacrifice, voluntary or possibly not, the concept of "supporting" troops if you are not willing to extend that past bumper stickers, and even deeper dives into the human psyche and the exchanges between groups of humans.
It's easier to pat the soil on those graves and to plant some violets on them. Or at least to remember.
Saturday, May 23, 2015
On The Duggar Ideology: Multiply At Any Cost.
Many have written about the recently revealed child molestation accusations against Josh Duggar, the oldest son of Michelle and Jim Bob Duggar, the Quiverfull parents of nineteen children whose lives are depicted in a now (temporarily?) withdrawn reality show 19 Kids and Counting.
The basic ideology of the Quiverfull movement is well summarized by the description of Kathryn Joyce's book* about the Christian patriarchy cult:
Kathryn Joyce's fascinating introduction to the world of the patriarchy movement and Quiverfull families examines the twenty-first-century women and men who proclaim self-sacrifice and submission as model virtues of womanhood—and as modes of warfare on behalf of Christ. Here, women live within stringently enforced doctrines of wifely submission and male headship, and live by the Quiverfull philosophy of letting God give them as many children as possible so as to win the religion and culture wars through demographic means.Hence the attempt to maximize family size, even if that might lead to the impossibility of adequately feeding, caring for, or supervising all those children. They are arrows in the war against the infidels, and the manufacture of the maximum number of such arrows requires the women's submission and compliance.
This is the proper background for interpreting what happened after Michelle and Jim Bob Duggar found that their fourteen-year-old son had fondled the breasts and genitals of minor girls, many of them apparently his own sisters, while they were supposedly asleep. The son was sent to therapy or perhaps just away for a while, a police officer (later sentenced for child pornography) gave him a stern speech and the girls who were fondled presumably forgave him.
The Duggars apologized for those events:
Back 12 years ago our family went through one of the most difficult times of our lives. When Josh was a young teenager, he made some very bad mistakes and we were shocked. We had tried to teach him right from wrong. That dark and difficult time caused us to seek God like never before. Even though we would never choose to go through something so terrible, each one of our family members drew closer to God. We pray that as people watch our lives they see that we are not a perfect family. We have challenges and struggles everyday. It is one of the reasons we treasure our faith so much because God’s kindness and goodness and forgiveness are extended to us — even though we are so undeserving. We hope somehow the story of our journey — the good times and the difficult times — cause you to see the kindness of God and learn that He can bring you through anything.
Let me see what's included there: God's forgiveness? Check. What the family gained from the events? Check. Josh's "bad mistakes? Sort of check.
What the daughters went through?
Crickets...
And that's the fundamental problem with the Quiverfull ideology and those right-wing Christian beliefs which suggest that victims of abuse should bear responsibility for it happening, that God may have allowed it because of something the victim did or failed to do.
I stress this ideology, because it is what all the choices** of Duggars are based on and it is ultimately what their reality show is disseminating as a good conservative way of life.
-----
*I strongly recommend that book, by the way. Kathryn's work is always painstaking and objective.
**Read that. It's funny. Then send me money.
Friday, May 22, 2015
Lock Up Your Women. Advice from Chechnya.
Or from its president, to men in his country and probably everywhere. It's always educational to realize how very rare gender equality is in this world, of course, though I hate being reminded of that. But in a slightly different sense this whole story really is about a place where powerful men don't even have to pretend to view women as co-citizens.
Here's what happened:
Ramzan A. Kadyrov, the pugnacious president of the southern Republic of Chechnya and a close ally of President Vladimir V. Putin, finally had enough Wednesday of social media users’ mocking him relentlessly for seeming to push polygamy.
His solution? Keep women locked up at home and off social media.
“Lock them in, do not let them go out, and they will not post anything,” Mr. Kadyrov said in a video to a sheepish group of men and women who kept their arms folded across their chests and their eyes firmly on the ground during the harangue.
The scene, filmed at what appears to be his government palace and broadcast on local television, was prompted by what Mr. Kadyrov, who has long shown a flair for hyperbole, described as “The Wedding of the Millennium.”
The social media explosion was set off last weekend in Grozny, the Chechen capital, when a 17-year-old bride was married off to a pal of Mr. Kadyrov’s, a district police chief pushing 50 and reportedly already married.
The first report of the betrothal had emerged in late April in the Novaya Gazeta newspaper, which reported that the police chief, Nazhud Guchigov, had ordered the young woman’s parents to hand her over by May 2 or he would take her by force.
After the article was published, Mr. Kadyrov jumped into the action, saying he had investigated the marriage proposal and found both the young bride, Kheda Goylabiyeva, and her family agreeable.
Poor, poor bride. She looks scared and miserable in her wedding dress, while the thirty years older groom looks, well, determined and expectant.
But wait! There's more:
Pavel Astakhov, the Kremlin official who is supposed to protect children’s rights in Russia, defended the practice of older men taking young brides. During a radio interview, he suggested that was especially the case in places like Chechnya where women were “shriveled” by the age of 27, looking at that age like most Russian women do at 50.Astakhov is the officer who is supposed to protect children's rights in Russia! I wonder how he was chosen for the job.
His remarks prompted another wave of outrage, with hundreds of Russian women in their 20s posting pictures with the hashtag #wrinkledwomen. Mr. Astakhov apologized, saying that women of all ages were “wonderful and delightful.”
Astakhov's apology is worth quoting in full, because it so clearly reflects traditional gender roles and because it shows he doesn't get it at all:
"Women of any age are splendid and adorable," he writes. "God created Woman so that we could love her, defend her, take care of her, glorify her. A clumsy comparison, a rash word taken out of the context of discourse cannot change my attitude to the Fair Sex. I've loved, love and shall love and respect [them]! I apologize for the mistake I've made!"
Mmm. Tastes like 1950s America to me.
There are two points to this post:
First, most of this globe is terrible on gender equity, some places being pure hell (Islamic State) and many others showing the types of values this story demonstrates, or "traditional" values which almost always define women as second-class citizens whose concerns can be fairly safely ignored in most politics.
Second, things are changing, albeit slowly. Russian women protested the forced marriage of a young girl to a district police chief and the fact that this police officer (!) was breaking the law by already having at least one wife, and they also ridiculed the inanities which leaked out of Astakhov's mouth. That horse cannot be returned to its patriarchal stable.
Still, isn't the statement "lock up your women" just utterly delicious? It's the perfect summary of assumed male supremacy: The women are yours and you have the right to lock them up.*
-------
*This doesn't mean that Russian or Chechen men would necessarily think like that. But president Kadyrov clearly does.
Thursday, May 21, 2015
Fundraising Day Four. On Fox News As The Alternative To Me.
You got yesterday off from my whining! And tomorrow is the last day. Thanks for your contributions to this blog. Not only the financial ones!
My arm is still broken, but it doesn't hurt much. I will find out tomorrow what happens next.
Staccato writing... That and conciseness are my trademarks, together with a measly vocabulary.
I was going to write about The Endangered White Guys Television which is Fox News. Even their woman-dominated program is called Outnumbered! But instead of a long rumination on that topic, let me just quote from Media Matters for America:
Fox's Tantaros: "The Last Acceptable Form Of Discrimination In This Country Is Against White Men"
Fox Host To Actresses Suffering Pay Discrimination: "Be Grateful" You Get To Star Alongside Famous Men
Andrea Tantaros: "I Do Think There's Different Wiring Between Men And Women, Where Women May Want To Go Have Kids And Stay At Home"
Fox Business' Gasparino: "Overt Feminization Of Our Culture" Has Created A Situation Where "Men Are Becoming Women"
And that's just in the last ten days or so! I could go on for a long time about the illogicality of being "wired" to stay at home (what happened to those nomadic hunter-gatherers who evolutionary psychologists believe were the group for all that wiring? or are we back in the 1970s cave-wife cartoons?) and the awkward juxtapositioning of "natural" sex roles with the idea that men are now becoming women (heh).
See what you get if you don't support this blog?
#SayHerName
Is trending on Twitter. It's about the Black Lives Matter movement, only this time about Black Women's and Girls' Lives mattering. The overall context is complex, having to do with the lost childhoods of black girls, racist versions of sexism and sexist versions of racism, income inequality, wings cut short before the time to fly and much more.
But it is also about the way the police treats black women and about the way that treatment doesn't quite produce the same protests as similar outrages experienced by black men.
I don't have statistical data on the gender distribution of those who are killed by the police, or the underlying data on contacts with the police by men and women of all racial and ethnic groups, but even if men die more frequently in the hands of the police, it still looks like their individual cases get more coverage and more protests. For example:
It is clear that #BlackLivesMatter struggles to generate as much concern for the safety and welfare of black women as it does for black men. The death of Natasha McKenna in the Fairfax County jail is a case in point.
McKenna, who suffered from mental illness, was shocked four times with a Taser stun gun by a sheriff’s deputy. She was in coma for several days before she died. A “Students March for Natasha McKenna” was supposed to have been held earlier in May to protest her death, which was ruled accidental. But the march has been postponed because of a lack of participation.
A meeting to discuss ways to drum up more interest in the march was scheduled for Tuesday in Fairfax City. More than 300 were invited on Facebook. Only 35 have confirmed, with 26 saying maybe.
We must do better.
Wednesday, May 20, 2015
Today's Research Popularization Fail
Several summaries of a study about online dating attracted my beady eyes recently. The study, supposedly telling us that more groomed dating photographs affect heterosexual men and women differently, looked useful grist for my mill. For instance:
Researchers at the University of Connecticut conducted an experiment to determine how people judged each other based on their online dating profile photos. They presented 671 volunteers with a single photo that was either casual or enhanced and of a man or a woman. Researchers reported that men were less likely to trust women who posted an "enhanced" photo with good angles, good lighting and make-up.Bolds are mine, and they are very important bolds.
But that didn't stop the men wanting to date those women anyway, said lead study author Rory McGloin, a communications professor at UConn.
"They thought she was more attractive, they wanted to go on a date with her ... but they didn't trust her," McGloin said.
On the flip side, women found men with enhanced photos to be more trustworthy, according to their findings, which is set to be presented at the International Communication Association annual conference later this month.
Suppose that I tell you my research shows that hats created from aluminum foil really do keep Fox News from corrupting your brain. Suppose that I tell you I tested this with hundreds of individuals. But nope, you CANNOT see the research paper, even though all you have is my word about the results! After all, I'm going to read it aloud to some colleagues in a few weeks!
I'm not accusing the researchers of making anything up. But to popularize a paper which nobody can get hold of is extremely bad manners. Even unethical, because of this:
Let's say that some paper popularized this way turns out to be utter rubbish (such as my tinfoil study). When the criticisms come in, the popularizers are no longer at all interested in correcting their earlier messages, so readers are left believing in lies. Here's one example of a retracted study which was widely popularized, but its retraction got no publicity. More examples here.
For the sake of completeness I should mention that I asked Mr. McGloin for the paper by e-mail. That was ten days ago, but if I get his answer I will write more about online dating and mating.
Tuesday, May 19, 2015
Fundraising Day Two. Flat Heels, Ties Or Codpieces?
I bet you wonder if this begging thing ends soon... I'm using the donations to partially gauge readership etc., to learn if I should go on or not. That's today's knot to unravel.
The instructions for giving are in the left column.
The rest of the title has to do with this story:
The Cannes Film Festival is reportedly not allowing women into screenings if they’re wearing flat shoes. I’m not sure I could’ve come up with a better metaphor for sexism in the film industry if I was really, really trying. If you wrote this into a novel about sexism in the film industry, it would seem heavy-handed. “Too much,” your editor would say. “Tone it down.”Flatgate erupted on Twitter this week after several women were apparently turned away from a red carpet screening of Cate Blanchett’s new movie Carol because they were in the demon flats.
So I lean back and ask if this is any different from men having to wear ties (does the Cannes Film Festival require that?) or visible codpieces, perhaps with tassels (that could be fun)?
The main difference is that high heels have possibly serious health consequences for their wearers (you could even fall and break your humerus! though I fell barefooted), and unless ties are so tight as to strangle the wearer, my other examples do not. And the rule, if real, discriminates against women who already have health problems which make heels impossible to wear.
----
Added later: Three guys plan to wear high heels in solidarity.
The Regrets Of History. By David Brooks.
Brooks' newest column is on the inexplicable and illogical Bush decision to invade Iraq, because of bin Laden who was known not to be there and because of oil, naturally. If we believe Brooks, history is HARD to learn:
Which brings us to Iraq. From the current vantage point, the decision to go to war was a clear misjudgment, made by President George W. Bush and supported by 72 percent of the American public who were polled at the time. I supported it, too.
What can be learned?
...
The Iraq war error reminds us of the need for epistemological modesty. We don’t know much about the world, and much of our information is wrong. A successful president has to make decisions while radiating hesitancy, staying open-minded in the face of new evidence, not falling into the traps that afflict those who possess excessive self-confidence.
Time to tear out whatever hair we might have left. The whole fiasco was a fiasco, decisions made by politicians who acted like they had never read about the history of Iraq, the arbitrary nature of the country, the Sunnis and the Shias and the Kurds. For goddess' sake, Bush sent out freshly-hatched AynRandians to build Free Markets there!
As I said (repeatedly), it was a fiasco, and nothing Brooks wrote makes it any less so. It's NOT the case that those in power can just make up policy as they go (well, it worked in Russia..). That's a high school student essay level work. And no, it doesn't make any difference if the majority of Americans supported the invasion, because they were not the experts who needed to be heard.
Then Brooks, the eternal optimistic preacher, tells us that the farce, the fiasco, was at least a partial success. Ask what people fleeing Ramadi think of that! Sadly, you can't ask the opinions of all those who died because of the invasion.
ISIS would probably exist even in the absence of the Bush invasion, because its real breeding grounds were in Syria. But surely the American invasion and the removal of Sunnis from power prepared the fields in Iraq for its seeds of religious fanaticism, cruelty, slavery and extreme Saudi-type patriarchy, the harvest to be watered with blood.
Monday, May 18, 2015
Fundraising Day One. The Price Is Right.
I traveled a bit last week, surfing through living-rooms where Fox News provides the only reality one can trust and the only '"news" one can rely on. Frightening experiences! The world looks very different when half the news on other channels are missing and the remaining ones are blown out of all proportion.
But on television I was really affected by this show: The Price Is Right.
To participate in it you have to suffer from St. Vitus Dance whenever you see a waffle-iron or a toaster. Or move by making only rabbit jumps and squeal a lot. It's a quiz show, and the attraction to the viewers just might be how silly people can be made to act for some money.
Or perhaps not, and now I feel mean and heartless. But surely better programs are affordable in a country which spends enormous sums on its military? Now I can't help thinking of the US military being governed by squealing and jumping generals.
Speaking of money, the official fundraising for this blog has begun. Thanks to all who already gave and thanks to all whom I'm mesmerizing here to give. As always, don't feel bad if you can't give. I value all my readers.
Friday, May 15, 2015
An Oldie But Goodie: Why Would Walmart Hire Any Men If Women Are Cheaper And Equally Productive?
This is the "aha! got you there!" argument I often hear from those who believe that firms couldn't possibly discriminate AND remain profitable. After all, a firm which could save on its labor costs by not discriminating would make higher profits, right?
The shadow side of that argument is naturally the assumption that women are worse workers and deserve lower pay.
A response to all this can be found in this post.
It's worth reading if you often engage with people making the above argument.
Thursday, May 14, 2015
First Convict the Perpetrator. On True And False Rape Accusations
Anti-feminists and MRAs frequently write about the fear of false rape accusations, the idea that a man's life can be ruined just on some woman's say-so.
Those stories and Twitter messages see false rape accusations as a giant problem, perhaps amounting to half of all accusations! That the best studies suggest rates much, much lower* doesn't make the smallest dent to the edifice of "known knowns" created in that alternative reality of manosphere,** because outside information is ignored there.
Given all that, I found this story about a sexual assault conviction fascinating:
Bolds are mine. Get it? This is the gist:
If this "perfect" type of sexual assault by a stranger has such a hard time getting convictions, what are the chances in cases where the victim knew the perpetrator?
The specific reason why the legal system favored Clifford seems to be the inadmissibility of prior evidence in Maryland:
What makes this example crucial in the false-accusations context is this: Based on the way MRAs use the concept the three women who lost their cases against Clifford would have been counted among those falsely accusing someone of sexual assault. After all, the court found for Clifford in each case.
-------
* The best estimates are between 2% and 8% of all rape accusations.
** And fascinating theories about the reasons why men should be the revered bosses of women, both viewed as classes. For instance, I recently read that women should make sandwiches to men, because men built the cities (and presumably gave them freely to those women who made them sandwiches), and it takes a lot of sandwiches to build a city.
That's a good example of the nuttier manosphere arguments. Note the view of all men as builders of cities, the view of women's contributions to civilizations as zero, the omission of who built the men themselves and so on.
It's in the same family as arguments that all women should make all men sandwiches because certain men died in the wars. It's not the dead warriors who deserve the sandwiches, but anyone with the same y-chromosome.
Then never mind that women have been banned from the military, in the past had little say over whether countries would go to war or not, and still face sexual harassment in construction jobs.
But none of that matters, because the point of those arguments is not gender equality but the perpetuation of male supremacy.
Those stories and Twitter messages see false rape accusations as a giant problem, perhaps amounting to half of all accusations! That the best studies suggest rates much, much lower* doesn't make the smallest dent to the edifice of "known knowns" created in that alternative reality of manosphere,** because outside information is ignored there.
Given all that, I found this story about a sexual assault conviction fascinating:
Baltimore jury convicted a man Friday who had been acquitted in four previous sexual assault trials, a win for prosecutors who revived the discarded case in a bid to secure an elusive conviction.
Nelson Bernard Clifford, a convicted sex offender, was found guilty of two counts of third-degree sex offense. While the counts individually carry a maximum sentence of 10 years, prosecutors say Clifford faces an enhanced penalty — up to life in prison — because of prior convictions.
Prosecutors said that on Sept. 30, 2007, Clifford broke into a woman's home in the Barclay neighborhood, tied her hands with a belt and sexually assaulted her. Clifford also was found guilty of theft for stealing the victim's laptop and $45, prosecutors said.
Bolds are mine. Get it? This is the gist:
Clifford had gone to trial four times since 2010. In each case, the women said he broke into their homes and bound and attacked them. Each time, he took the stand and claimed that the encounters were consensual, and was acquitted of the most serious charges.
If this "perfect" type of sexual assault by a stranger has such a hard time getting convictions, what are the chances in cases where the victim knew the perpetrator?
The specific reason why the legal system favored Clifford seems to be the inadmissibility of prior evidence in Maryland:
Prosecutors were dealt a setback before the most recent case, after trying to enjoin it with another to show a pattern. Clifford allegedly attacked a woman and stole her phone, which was left behind at the scene of a second attack four days later. But Chief Judge Alfred J. Nance ruled the cases be tried separately. On the witness stand, Clifford acknowledged leaving the phone behind, but jurors had no idea it was stolen from another alleged victim.
What makes this example crucial in the false-accusations context is this: Based on the way MRAs use the concept the three women who lost their cases against Clifford would have been counted among those falsely accusing someone of sexual assault. After all, the court found for Clifford in each case.
-------
* The best estimates are between 2% and 8% of all rape accusations.
** And fascinating theories about the reasons why men should be the revered bosses of women, both viewed as classes. For instance, I recently read that women should make sandwiches to men, because men built the cities (and presumably gave them freely to those women who made them sandwiches), and it takes a lot of sandwiches to build a city.
That's a good example of the nuttier manosphere arguments. Note the view of all men as builders of cities, the view of women's contributions to civilizations as zero, the omission of who built the men themselves and so on.
It's in the same family as arguments that all women should make all men sandwiches because certain men died in the wars. It's not the dead warriors who deserve the sandwiches, but anyone with the same y-chromosome.
Then never mind that women have been banned from the military, in the past had little say over whether countries would go to war or not, and still face sexual harassment in construction jobs.
But none of that matters, because the point of those arguments is not gender equality but the perpetuation of male supremacy.
Wednesday, May 13, 2015
The Conservative War Against Teachers. Or How To Shoot At Your Own Foot.
US conservatives have an odd schizophrenic angle to the power of markets: They are all-important (godlike, even), and must not be meddled with in finance, for instance, but when it comes to teaching professions those same markets can be totally ignored. Indeed, the conservatives like a command economy there, as in "We command, teachers obey."
The point I've made before is that conservatives shouldn't completely ignore markets in their attempts to behead the political power of all teachers' unions.
To give you an example, cutting back on teachers' retirement benefits means cutting back on their total compensation packages. In Chicago, for instance:
What do you think a seven-percent compensation cut would mean for the supply of new teachers? Remember that they must invest in a college degree which is not getting cheaper, even as the financial pay in the occupation declines.
Here's the answer:
This is another case of short-sighted politically motivated dinners where the politicians happily eat the seed corn to make sure that the Democrats don't get today's bread.
The topic matters for women's employment. Traditionally*, teaching has been one of the few areas which has allowed an easier combination of childcare duties with paid work (getting home at the same time as the kids, being at home during their vacations). The lower pay, compared to other jobs which have similar college investment requirements, has been acceptable because of that flexibility. But if the pay keeps going down further we will see a drop in the supply of teachers and the quality of the incoming teachers.
----
*In the bad-old days US women had three somewhat wide job paths into middle class earnings. They were teaching, social work and being a secretary. See what is happening to teaching, then read what is happening to secretarial jobs, and the importance of opening the IT jobs to more women looks pretty clear.
The point I've made before is that conservatives shouldn't completely ignore markets in their attempts to behead the political power of all teachers' unions.
To give you an example, cutting back on teachers' retirement benefits means cutting back on their total compensation packages. In Chicago, for instance:
The district, which says it is wrestling with a $1.1 billion deficit weighted with pension payments, wants to save millions of dollars by having teachers pay more into their pension fund. The district wants to end a long-standing agreement that limits teacher paycheck deductions for pensions, the union said.
That CTU said the result would be a 7 percent cut in take-home pay for members. The union also says health care premiums could take another 3 percent under a district proposal.
What do you think a seven-percent compensation cut would mean for the supply of new teachers? Remember that they must invest in a college degree which is not getting cheaper, even as the financial pay in the occupation declines.
Here's the answer:
The number of students interested in becoming educators continues to drop significantly—From 2010 to 2014, the number of ACT-tested high school graduates interested in education majors or professions decreased by more than 16%, while the number of all graduates who took the ACT increased by nearly 18%.Those who express interest in teaching tend to score lower in all areas except English than those who express no such interest.
This is another case of short-sighted politically motivated dinners where the politicians happily eat the seed corn to make sure that the Democrats don't get today's bread.
The topic matters for women's employment. Traditionally*, teaching has been one of the few areas which has allowed an easier combination of childcare duties with paid work (getting home at the same time as the kids, being at home during their vacations). The lower pay, compared to other jobs which have similar college investment requirements, has been acceptable because of that flexibility. But if the pay keeps going down further we will see a drop in the supply of teachers and the quality of the incoming teachers.
----
*In the bad-old days US women had three somewhat wide job paths into middle class earnings. They were teaching, social work and being a secretary. See what is happening to teaching, then read what is happening to secretarial jobs, and the importance of opening the IT jobs to more women looks pretty clear.
Tuesday, May 12, 2015
Mothers' Day Political Thoughts
1. The political respect for motherhood is a bit like buying one of those "I Support The Troops" bumper stickers (made in China and very cheap) and then voting against any veterans' benefits.
2. That's why the myth of the all-sacrificing female parent as the sole caregiver of children is so popular! A special day once every year and no need for paid parental leave! Because mothers are intended to self-sacrifice, so nobody else will have to. This is an extreme example of how a proper mother should spend her life. Note the guilt, note the need to erase all other parts of one's personality, and then note that all this is internalized: The job of parenting belongs solely to mothers and its cost is pretty much everything else.
3. That's the shadow side of basic libertarian* thinking, too, which stinks of Nietzsche. If the Übermensch is to be mostly free (free!), then the Untermensch cannot be. Someone must wipe the butts and wash the diapers, but having done so will always count against the person in the labor market. You must take time off to be a Good Mother but you will be punished for taking that time off.
4. None of this means that fathers of children wouldn't be expected to take responsibility for their children. But traditionally that responsibility coincides much better with a person's other goals in life: You can advance in your career, get promoted, satisfy some of your ambitions, and nobody asks who is minding your children or how they cope with your absences. Granted, the monetary consequences are not good for either mothers or fathers who take time off from the labor force. Still, we expect less hands-on care or presence from fathers and guilt them much less for the choice to continue working hard.
5. The problems of the mythologically decreed Supermom, working mostly on her own, are much exacerbated for some groups of women of color and for poorer women. Staying at home is not an option if you are the breadwinner of the family or if the earnings of two adults are necessary, good quality daycare may be unaffordable. Those single mothers who qualify for government assistance are often viewed as parasites sucking the blood of upstanding taxpayers.
This provocative story is by a black woman who chose not to have children because she knew she was expected to do it all on her own.
6. The bumper sticker view of motherhood in this country means that the US is one of the few countries where maternal mortality rates are rising, and also one of the few industrialized countries where there is no nationwide policy for paid maternity leave, not to speak of paid paternity leave.
Though the reasons for the former are complex, they clearly intersect with poverty and race. The latter we may thank the conservatives and corporations for. You may have heard that paid parental leave would handicap American corporations which have to compete against foreign firms. Possibly even firms located in countries which already have paid (and long!) parental leave. Gasp.
7. These points are about political thoughts about motherhood, not general or philosophical thoughts. Thus, they are not intended to negate the wonders of parenthood or to imply that the respect for individual mothers wouldn't be real. But politicians are not meant to focus on the latter. They are meant to create the support systems which parenting requires. And in that sense this country gets a failing grade.
---------
* This libertarian angle crops up in the onus put on individuals rather than the wider society:
Rather than making the environment safer and healthier for children, the onus is put on the parents, and especially on mothers, beginning from pregnancy: Mercury in tuna? It's your responsibility not to eat it while pregnant. No sidewalks for school children to use to walk to school? It's your responsibility to drive them, and when they get fat from lack of exercise, that, too, is your responsibility. And we won't even ask the question what a parent without a car should do.
The counterargument is that people shouldn't have kids if they cannot do all that. But children are the next generation and will become the future caregivers, doctors, dentists, farmers and so on; the people who will one day take care of the old people that even today's young and childless libertarians turn into. This shared aspect of the value of children is one reason why the society should support good parenting.
Friday, May 08, 2015
Deep Thoughts for Today
Especially for online debates:
Never quitting an argument does not equal having won.
On learning Dragon Dictate (a speech recognition system I bought to get around that broken humerus):
Text that I read:
Testing Dragon Dictate by Echidne. This is unedited.
How Dragon heard it first time:
Testing Dragon dictate by A Kidman. These is on anything
And second time:
Testing Dragon Dictate by a kidney. Base is on 18
And third time:
Testing Dragon Dictate by ECH I D and E. Base is on NDT
I'm enjoying chatting to the Dragon!
On the Jade Helm 15 conspiracy theories which are wild in Texas:
Remember that this is the state which has exorbitant influence on the textbooks for US schools.
If I were located in another galaxy I'd have lots of fun with this juxtaposition.
Never quitting an argument does not equal having won.
On learning Dragon Dictate (a speech recognition system I bought to get around that broken humerus):
Text that I read:
Testing Dragon Dictate by Echidne. This is unedited.
How Dragon heard it first time:
Testing Dragon dictate by A Kidman. These is on anything
And second time:
Testing Dragon Dictate by a kidney. Base is on 18
And third time:
Testing Dragon Dictate by ECH I D and E. Base is on NDT
I'm enjoying chatting to the Dragon!
On the Jade Helm 15 conspiracy theories which are wild in Texas:
Remember that this is the state which has exorbitant influence on the textbooks for US schools.
If I were located in another galaxy I'd have lots of fun with this juxtaposition.
Thursday, May 07, 2015
Get Some Male Co-Authors To Improve Your Paper. That's One Reviewer's Advice For Two Female Biologists.
Here's a fun story (from a week ago) about the lives of female academics. Well, not all their lives and perhaps nowadays even only small snippets of their lives, but this stuff is still part of the musty smell of academic gowns:
Fiona Ingleby [and Megan Head] wrote a paper on the difficulties of making the transition from graduate school to post-doctoral position for women. She submitted it for review. A review is kind of an invited comment, you know, so given Lewis’ Law, I guess we shouldn’t be surprised at what followed — she got a negative review that actually justified the contents of her paper.
Get it? Men can run faster and therefore men must be better researchers! But women are, on average, more flexible than men. Maybe women write more complicated papers?
Duh. Both comparisons are idiotic. Which means the review is idiotic, too.
But wait! It gets better:
Would those men have to be very fast runners, too? The reviewer believes that men are superior thinkers, runners and -- probably -- reviewers. If we employ those pesky 'ideologically biased assumptions.' By the way, I'd really like to see the empirical evidence that demonstrates better health and stamina among the men in the relevant age group.
The journal whose editor passed these anonymous comments to Ingleby reacted promptly:
PLOS ONE has strict policies for how we expect peer review to be performed and we strive to ensure that the process is fair and civil. We have taken a number of steps to remedy the situation. We have formally removed the review from the record, and have sent the manuscript out to a new editor for re-review. We have also asked the Academic Editor who handled the manuscript to step down from the Editorial Board and we have removed the referee from our reviewer database.
Which is the correct thing to do. Not because the reviewer suggested that the authors should consider average gender differences in the quality of the papers as one possible hypothesis to be examined*, but because he/she didn't say that.
Instead, he/she assumed that the poor little ladies need burly shoulders to lean on and masculine brains to borrow to get anything done.
I can't now get rid of the imagery of male biology graduate students sprinting around campus fountains, clad as ancient Greek Olympians were, the winner of the race getting the laurel wreath and the best publication placements, while the feeble and sickly female graduate students sit on the lawn under pink parasols and applaud.
----
*Or rather, the authors should try to hold the quality of papers constant while studying, say, any differential treatment of male and female researchers.
Added later: The importance of this case is in the way anonymous reviews are used to decide which article gets published in which journal. So they have power.
On the other hand, the final acceptance rates by gender could be used in later research to determine how good men and women are in research. Cases like the one above are unlikely to be common, but they point out that something which is supposed to be a somewhat objective assessment of the quality of the work (a peer review) may not be that at all.
Tuesday, May 05, 2015
A Blog-Keeping Post
When is the best time for my annual fund-drive (aka begging)? That is really asking when you (sweet, erudite and generous readers) have the most money I can wheedle off you.
Without a better answer, I'm going to declare next week for that unpleasant (for you) but necessary (for me) task. Or you can give now or later. If affording it is hard, do not worry. I value all my readers. But this blog doesn't come completely free, even if I assigned my own labor zero value.
I'd also like to remind you all of my ISIS-and-women series, what with this argument I just heard on Twitter about how Western feminazis want jazz hands but are silent about the Yazidi women. The series still lacks the final post, but the others are linked to at the bottom of this introductory post. Including the one about the Yazidi girls and women.
Without a better answer, I'm going to declare next week for that unpleasant (for you) but necessary (for me) task. Or you can give now or later. If affording it is hard, do not worry. I value all my readers. But this blog doesn't come completely free, even if I assigned my own labor zero value.
I'd also like to remind you all of my ISIS-and-women series, what with this argument I just heard on Twitter about how Western feminazis want jazz hands but are silent about the Yazidi women. The series still lacks the final post, but the others are linked to at the bottom of this introductory post. Including the one about the Yazidi girls and women.
The Venus de Milo, a Spinster?
What might the statue we call the Venus de Milo depict? What is she doing?
Given her missing arms it's hard to know. The most recent attempt to reconstruct her arms and figure out her possible task uses 3D-printing and the theory that she was spinning thread, a very common task for women all over the world in the past and still in some places.
Virginia Postrel's piece in Slate also mentions several other theories, and clearly we cannot just conclude that the statue depicts a spinster (initially a term for a woman who spins and here used by me as a bad pun, because of the treatment of the statue in more glorified ways as the epitome of female beauty).*
But it's a good hypothesis. She writes:
Barber, a professor emeritus at Occidental College and the doyenne of textile archeology, proffers a thesis the 19th-century critics never debated. She imagines Venus doing something that occupied endless hours of women’s time before the Industrial Revolution: spinning thread. She suggests that the statue held a distaff of fluffy fibers in her upraised left arm, while with her right she guided the thread toward a weighted drop spindle hanging in front of her. “This was a pose painfully familiar to women in ancient Greek society,” Barber notes.
Hence the 3D-print testing.
What struck me a bit weird about the whole approach is that it doesn't use the expertise of those women who still spin in the same manner. From Peru:
They would know if the reconstruction looks feasible** and what the odd twist in the statue's back might mean to them, if anything.
-----
* Wonder what her waist-to-hip ratio might be? That's for evolutionary psychologists who believe that men have always preferred the same ratio and humongous breasts on women.
**Other than the apparently falling fabric around her hips. Perhaps she is twisting to stop it falling further? Just kidding.
Monday, May 04, 2015
Meanwhile. in Paraguay
A ten-year-old girl was raped, allegedly by her stepfather, and cannot get an abortion because of the Catholic church, ultimately. Abortion is only available when the pregnant person's life is at risk.
This quote angered me:
The 10-year-old is one of three children who share a rented room in the city of Luque with her mother and stepfather.
The mother, who works in a school cafeteria, reported in January 2014 that her husband was sexual abusing her daughter, but the authorities took no action. When the girl’s stomach started to swell and ache last month, the mother took her to hospital fearing she may have a tumour.
After doctors revealed the girl was pregnant, her mother asked them to perform an abortion, but this is forbidden in Paraguay unless the pregnancy has life-threatening complications.
The girl was taken to a shelter and her mother was imprisoned on 27 April and accused of failing in her duty of care. A judge is considering a further charge of being an accomplice in the rape. The stepfather is on the run.
Bolds are mine.
Note the poverty of the girl's mother. Note that she went to the authorities and was ignored. Note that she is now imprisoned for failing in her duty of care.
What may be demanded of mothers is very different from what may be demanded of everyone else, including the authorities.
Saturday, May 02, 2015
Limbaugh Being Limbaugh Again
He thinks the LGBT movement would be more understandable if there were more LGBT people. Like how did a small minority take over our politics? And no, he is not talking about the Koch brothers.
Hmm. Let's see if our Rush then thinks that women's rights are a more understandable movement. After all, around half of all humans are of the female persuasion.
Nope.
A Public Health Announcement
Don't fall down the stairs. You can break your shoulder bone in the more sentient of your arms. It's not only somewhat painful, but also leaves you with the pecking/typing ability of five fingers which are sinister.
In other words, my posts will be short until I learn single-hand typing superpowers.
The silver lining in this cloud is a chance to do real research on health care costs. For example, the shoulder immobilizer the ER gave me will cost either me or the insurer between 63 and 110 dollars. Identical (or better) are for sale online for less than 30 dollars. This may reflect the markup pricing hospitals practice.
Thursday, April 30, 2015
Girl Brains And Boy Brains, Take #456789. By Dr. Michael Mosley, Again!
I read this UK Daily Mail article with a very strong sense of déjà vu again. Didn't I fairly recently write about it? In last September, to be exact.
And indeed I did! Most, if not all, of the piece is recycled from an earlier piece.
Here's one of the glorious quotes from Dr. Mosley:
Professor Simon Baron-Cohen, an expert on the brain who I visited at Cambridge University, has done a lot of pioneering work on this. He believes, broadly, that people of whatever gender fall somewhere along a ‘systemiser’ to ‘empathiser’ spectrum.
Systemisters are people who enjoy breaking down and analysing systems. They are more likely to become train spotters or computer scientists.
They are what he has called ‘male brained’ — as these qualities occur most frequently, but far from exclusively, in men.
Empathisers, on the other hand, are more typically ‘female’ brained as they are more typically women.
Although there are exceptions, most men — when tested — come out as more ‘systemising’ than ‘empathising’, while for women it is the other way round.
And this is the picture we are given of systemisers!
I love it! Lovelovelove it! It's a beautiful example of biased thinking. Examples of systemizing behavior are all picked from stuff guys do more and that means systemizing is a male brain thing. But of course many traditionally female hobbies and chores also require good systemizing skills. If you omit all of those and put in a picture of train spotting guys, well, you have made your case.
There's so much wrong with this repeat article. Read my prior post for some of my criticisms and this 2010 post on the digit length comparisons.
Tuesday, April 28, 2015
Short Posts, 4/28/2015: Fear of the Other Party, Why Reproductive Rights Might Be Losing, the Power of Koch Brothers And Older Actresses
1. This study on the fear of the other political party in the US sounds interesting. I have not read the study itself, so I can't say anything about its methods and such. But thinking about the "fear of the other" in the context of political parties could be fruitful.
2. Katha Pollitt writes about the reasons why same-sex marriage is winning and reproductive rights are losing in the US. I'm not sure if I agree with every one of her points but the list is another good starting place for thinking. In general, women's rights on the global level don't get the support they should because the change required is so large. After all, women are roughly half of all human beings. That's my positive interpretation of people having to be dragged kicking and screaming into the modern era. The sadder interpretations is, well, sad, and has to do with the question who controls this resource called "women."
3. Après moi, le déluge" Or Koch-backed think tank is sending scientists to the Vatican, to school the Pope:
“The Holy Father is being misled by ‘experts’ at the United Nations who have proven unworthy of his trust,” said Joseph Bast, president of the Heartland Institute. “Humans are not causing a climate crisis on God’s Green Earth – in fact, they are fulfilling their Biblical duty to protect and use it for the benefit of humanity. Though Pope Francis’s heart is surely in the right place, he would do his flock and the world a disservice by putting his moral authority behind the United Nations’ unscientific agenda on the climate.”The French reference is to show you how erudite I am, even though Louis XV might never had said that as his last words. Also, I don't speak French.
He called on anyone with “open ears” to fulfill their moral duty to seek the truth on climate change – which 97 percent of scientists agree is likely the result of human activities.
“The science is not settled, and global warming is not a crisis,” Bast said. “The world’s poor will suffer horribly if reliable energy – the engine of prosperity and a better life – is made more expensive and less reliable by the decree of global planners.”
It's also because I smell that in the thinking of many Koch-type conservatives: Give us our profits and the heck with the future generations.
But it's also because the brothers Koch are wielding exorbitant power in American politics, much, much more than most voters. That power reminds me of the power of ancient French kings. And mostly the argument is that they can wield that power legally (funding political campaigns etc.) because of the freedom of expression. Something of the sort where each dollar note has the same right to express itself. That's bad news for any semblance of democracy.
4. This video is hilarious. It's about when older actresses are no longer f**kable. The language is not work-safe.
On Baltimore
The city of Baltimore is recovering after demonstrations and rioting this weekend. The cause of them was the death of Freddie Gray:
Authorities can't say if there was a particularly good reason why police arrested Gray. According to the city, an officer made eye contact with Gray, and he took off running, so they pursued him. Though he'd had scrapes with the law before, there's no indication he was wanted at the time. And though he was found with a switchblade, Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake said, “We know that having a knife is not necessarily a crime.”
The police say Gray didn't resist arrest and that officers didn't use force, which seems to be mostly corroborated by video shot by bystanders. Gray seems to shout in pain, and his leg seems injured as officers drag him to a police van. (Someone off camera shouts, "His leg broke and y'all dragging him like that!") Gray also had asthma and requested his inhaler, but didn't get it. Yet it's not the leg or the asthma that killed him. Instead, it was a grave injury to his spinal cord. Gray's family said he was treated for three fractured vertebrae and a crushed voice box, the sorts of injuries that doctors say are usually caused by serious car accidents. The van made at least two stops before reaching the police station, but there's no footage to say what happened during the journey or at those stops.
It's a baffling conundrum. "None of the officers describe any use of force," Deputy Police Commissioner Jerry Rodriguez said. "None of the officers describe using any force against Mr. Gray." And yet somehow Gray was fatally hurt while in police custody.
This case has similarities to other recent and not so recent cases, where an unarmed (or allegedly unarmed) person dies either when arrested or in police custody. The majority of these cases are about the deaths of black men and the usual way to package the issue is as one of police brutality and racism.
That may be convenient shorthand, as long as we remember that the racism might not necessarily be personal but institutional and that the brutality might be at least partly defined as the increasing militarization of the police (where the population to be policed then becomes the enemy).
Freddie Gray died. His funeral resulted in demonstrations which then resulted in riots. The Maryland National Guard was called in, a state of emergency was declared.
How to interpret all that?
That depends on the interpreter's perch. The conservative Rand Paul thinks the rioting is caused by lack of morals and fathers:*
As far as root causes, Paul listed some ideas of his own.
"There are so many things we can talk about," the senator said, "the breakdown of the family structure, the lack of fathers, the lack of a moral code in our society."
Ta-Nehisi Coates writes:
When nonviolence is preached as an attempt to evade the repercussions of political brutality, it betrays itself. When nonviolence begins halfway through the war with the aggressor calling time out, it exposes itself as a ruse. When nonviolence is preached by the representatives of the state, while the state doles out heaps of violence to its citizens, it reveals itself to be a con. And none of this can mean that rioting or violence is "correct" or "wise," any more than a forest fire can be "correct" or "wise." Wisdom isn't the point tonight. Disrespect is. In this case, disrespect for the hollow law and failed order that so regularly disrespects the community.
John Angelos, Chief Operating Officer of the Orioles, Baltimore’s major-league baseball franchise, notes the economic inequality and suffering:
That said, my greater source of personal concern, outrage, and sympathy beyond this particular case is focused neither upon one night’s property damage nor upon the acts, but is focused rather upon the past four-decade period during which an American political elite have shipped middle-class and working-class jobs away from Baltimore and cities and towns around the US to third-world dictatorships, like China and others; plunged tens of millions of good, hardworking Americans into economic devastation, and then followed that action around the nation by diminishing every American’s civil-rights protections in order to control an unfairly impoverished population living under an ever-declining standard of living and suffering at the butt end of an ever-more militarized and aggressive surveillance state.
Here's where the links to economic inequality and poverty matter. Consider the area of the city of Baltimore which Freddie Gray called home. These are the statistics applying to that area:
To understand why the demonstrations in Baltimore got out of hand we need to first understand what living in an area with those numbers means, what it does to you over time, and next relate all this to the history of the interactions between the Baltimore police and its black citizens.
None of that means that the riots would have been a "correct" response, as Coates observed in the above quote. They are a bad response, like shooting at your own leg because the real target is far too high to reach. But so were the riots after the Joe Paterno resignation at Penn State.
The difference is that many others don't now regard all Penn State students as possible rioters whereas they make just that generalization when it comes to certain residents of Baltimore.
-----
*In this context Rand Paul's own parenting skills do matter.
Saturday, April 25, 2015
To Help Nepal
You can send funds. The New York Times gives a list of aid organizations.
I was told that the Lutheran World Federation of Churches is also a good organization to give to. They have a lot of experience in crisis management, they do not try to convert people to Lutheranism and they seem to work on issues of gender justice, too.
I cannot personally vouch for any of the above, but they are avenues to get your pennies to make a difference.
As an aside, I really want to find a way to give help to the Yazidis in Iraq. If you know of a way, leave it in the comments, with my thanks.
Wednesday, April 22, 2015
The Apocalypse And Its Miscreants
So I start this post with the title and have to Google "miscreant!" That's how directly my posts are channeled from that goddess of snakes who takes me over.
Just joking. But also linking to the religious arguments about us living in end times. The valiant butchers of IS (ISIS/ISIL) believe that we are living in end times, and so do many American religious conservatives. To give you a slightly humorous take, here's Michele Bachmann on that topic:
Former Rep. Michele Bachmann (R-MN) expressed a mixture of condemnation and appreciation toward President Barack Obama for, in her words, bringing the world to end times.What a relief! I can stop flossing!
...
“Barack Obama is intent, it is his number one goal, to ensure that Iran has a nuclear weapon," she said. "Why? Why would you put the nuclear weapon in the hands of madmen who are Islamic radicals?"
Bachmann, however, then seemed to approve of the President moving mankind into "the midnight hour."
"We get to be living in the most exciting time in history," she said, urging fellow Christians to "rejoice."
"Jesus Christ is coming back. We, in our lifetimes potentially, could see Jesus Christ returning to Earth, the Rapture of the Church."
The point of this post is that something like "end times" is not an exogenous variable from the point of view of politicians and those active in trying to make them come about. "End times" can be achieved. A nuclear war could do it nicely, but so could many other things, such as irreversible changes in the climate.
The reverse of that is that we can delay the "end times" by our behavior. Sadly, people with certain religious views don't have any incentive to do so, because they have packed their suitcases and have their travel tickets for paradise tightly in one hand while they use the guns with the other.
I haven't read enough on the history of apocalyptic thoughts, but my guess is that there have always been many people who believed that they themselves were living in the "end times." But I doubt they had quite the same power to push this planet closer to them than some people today have. While rejoicing over it.
The Preference For Sons in India And China. Look What We got For it!
The Economist has a long and pretty fact-filled article on the consequences of the missing girls in India and China (sex-selective abortions and female infanticide), combined with a few other marriage rules. Worth reading it. You can also then read the comments if you wish.
I did. And then I got a sore stomach, as usual. The reasons are subtle, a bit like a giant hippo only showing its nose above the surface of the river. Everyone else writes about the nose, whereas I see the rest of that hippo, the ignored part.
Note that the article very quickly hints at the reason for all this sex imbalance: It's "preference for sons." Then it skates off to study how all those abortions and infant killings will soon leave many young men eternal spinsters (why not call them that?) and how that is very bad for the society and men, with more crime and violence and the need for more prostitutes.
The solutions offered both in the article and in the comments are not about that "preference for sons." If we realize that the same thing could be called "a dislike of daughters" or something much stronger, given that some parents even resort to killing the infant daughter, the disconnect between the problem (women are not valued) and the solutions offered (somehow get more women from elsewhere, say) becomes as clear as a hippo rising from the river.
The article has other interesting stuff, such as women "marrying upwards" in those countries. That's the same as men marrying downwards. Terms matter, my friends. Because if men marry downwards, it's better that there aren't too many women on the top of the societal ladders. They will become "leftovers" as they are called in China.
Now, the eternal spinster guys are also given pejorative names, such as "bare branches." But isn't it fascinating how something which has its roots in the fact that women are not valued results in an article where part of the problem of too many men is that educated women cannot find husbands? When you would have thought that more women with education (and thus more opportunities to help their families financially) would have been one of the solutions which could raise the valuation of women in general?
I may be nitpicking. But I have written about this particular slant in the media takes about the missing girls for many, many years. The problem really boils down, in those articles, to the question of how we can now get those men wives.
That the real problem is in the underlying assumption that all women are good for is being the providers of sex and sons just sorta sleeps under the surface of the debating river.
And yes, as I have written before, there are reasons for the dislike of daughters. In a system without good pensions it is the sons who are supposed to take care of their parents, while daughters must be provided with dowries and then they work for a totally different family. And it is the sons who are seen as continuing the family genes, only the sons. But all this, based on patrilocal marriage customs, is ultimately and circularly based on women not valued as much.
Monday, April 20, 2015
The Ethics of Journalism 101: Is it OK for NYT and WaPo to use Pre-Publication Opposition Research on Hillary Clinton?
This is an interesting question, even if I write so myself. The case for your consideration:
The New York Times, The Washington Post and Fox News have made exclusive agreements with a conservative author for early access to his opposition research on Hillary Clinton, a move that has confounded members of the Clinton campaign and some reporters, the On Media blog has confirmed.
"Clinton Cash: The Untold Story of How and Why Foreign Governments and Businesses Helped Make Bill and Hillary Rich" will debut on May 5. But the Times, the Post and Fox have already made arrangements with author Peter Schweizer to pursue some of the material included in his book, which seeks to draw connections between Clinton Foundation donations and speaking fees and Hillary Clinton's actions as secretary of state. Schweizer is the president of the Government Accountability Institute, a conservative research group, and previously served as an adviser to Republican vice presidential nominee Sarah Palin.
I see three potentially serious problems with these exclusive arrangements.
First, depending on what newspapers are supposed to have as their objective*, getting opposition research on only one candidate can bias the reporting in the papers. If conservative muckrakers are more diligent than liberal ones, the American people (how I love to be able to write that!) will be mislead, assuming that the Republican candidates might also have all sorts of skeletons in their mahogany cupboards.
Second, assuming that those at the newspapers know how to judge the research of Schweizer's book may be a form of hubris. Or at least we should not just be told that there will be experts looking at all the stuff.
Third, and this links to my second point, using a book BEFORE it is published means that the newspapers won't have access to the expert criticisms which follow the publication of a book. It's as if the book is allowed to hold the stage all alone, when the correct approach would be to wait to see what experts in the field might have to say about it.
----
*The naive me thinks that the newspapers should try to be objective, search for as much truth as people can agree on and provide voters with factual information that will help their votes. Psst, Maureen Dowd, writing about Hillary Clinton with all sorts of sexist terms isn't helpful for voters.
But other objectives are possible. For instance, to make the most money possible out of gullible readers.
Friday, April 17, 2015
Sam Brownback Likes Some Government Handouts And Hates Others
Don't you just adore governor Brownback? He's such an extreme believer in his own little right-wing religious fundamentalist reality. Even though it's Christianist, it's not very charitable. Or rather, the charity goes to the haves and is removed from the have-nots. I wonder what Jesus would say about that, hmh?
A few years ago Brownback cut taxes in Kansas something fierce. Indeed, certain kinds of firms don't pay any tax on their profits! That's giving the owners of those firms government handouts, in my divine and correct opinion.
But other types of handouts Brownback doesn't like. His most recent move consists of making absolutely sure that welfare recipients don't spend that grudgingly-offered money on strippers or tattoos but on useful things such as baby diapers:
The measure bars spending relief funds on movies, at swimming pools, or on "cruise ships," as well as at any "jewelry store, tattoo parlor, massage parlor, body piercing parlor ... psychic or fortune telling business, bail bond company, video arcade ... or any retail establishment which provides adult-oriented entertainment in which performers disrobe or perform in an unclothed state."
It also places a $25 daily limit on ATM withdrawals using the debit cards issued to recipients under the state/federal Temporary Assistance to Needy Families program, which is what's left of America's welfare program. That renders the cards useless for major spending, such as paying the rent, but it does mean that users will pile up ATM fees at $1 per withdrawal, plus bank fees.
Note that there is no evidence Kansas welfare recipients are desperately trying to use their welfare checks in the manner described here. I'd be pretty surprised if such misuse is at all common, given that most recipients are single mothers with young children.
The point of this bill, Brownback tells us, is to get people to go to work! I haven't checked if Kansas funds daycare for single mothers on welfare so that they can go to work in one of the minimum wage jobs many of them would end up with. But whatever. At least they can't get tattoos and massages while taking cruises.
Emily Badger in Washington Post writes about all this with great lucidity. She points out that the treatment of one group of handout recipients differs from the treatment of all other groups of handout recipients: They are held to higher moral and ethical standards:
The second issue with these laws is a moral one: We rarely make similar demands of other recipients of government aid. We don't drug-test farmers who receive agriculture subsidies (lest they think about plowing while high!). We don't require Pell Grant recipients to prove that they're pursuing a degree that will get them a real job one day (sorry, no poetry!). We don't require wealthy families who cash in on the home mortgage interest deduction to prove that they don't use their homes as brothels (because surely someone out there does this). The strings that we attach to government aid are attached uniquely for the poor.
And that is because we don't view other forms of government transfers as undeserved handouts.
It's not necessarily bad to limit what welfare payments can be used for. But when you combine this particular move with Brownback's earlier handouts to much wealthier groups of taxpayers you wonder what type of Jesus his reality has. If this man is supposedly following in his footsteps.
Thursday, April 16, 2015
Terry Pratchett Thoughts. On the Role of the Media and On Citizens as Consumers.
I've been re-reading many of Terry Pratchett's books, in his memory. I often come across little jewels (or chocolate truffles) of ideas. For example:
"the public is not interested in public interest."
Which is true. The reasons for that are many and varied, but it's almost impossible to try to write about topics of public interest on a commercial basis (so send money).
My most recent re-read is The Truth, about the first newspapers in Ankh-Morpork. Mr. William de Worde starts the very first one, with actual news in it (though also stories about funny-shaped vegetables). A competitor soon catches on with scandalous stories such as "a woman gives birth to a cobra."
de Worde gets a statement from the king of the area where this miracle-birth was supposed to have happened, at some cost for himself. The king denied any cobra-human births to have happened.
The response of the readers was that of course the king would deny everything, of course. In any case, stories about women giving birth to cobras are a lot more fun than stories about politics, say.
All that reminds me of American politics, in a gently ridiculous sense. Weird people writing or nattering about Hillary Clinton's cankles (a term for fat ankles) as if it matters what size ankles a president has and as if we ever otherwise measure the ankles of presidential contenders. Presidents being judged on the basis of whether we'd like to have a beer with them.
Imagine using that way of judging for picking your neurosurgeon.
All this links in a vague way to a Finnish article I recently came across, on the new approach to citizens as consumers. This is the part I wish to translate:
Kun on riittävän monta vuotta toisteltu, että kansa tietää parhaiten kaiken, ovat sivistysinstituutiot alkaneet nöyrtyä. Korkeakoulujen oletetaan palvelevan paitsi liike-elämää ja politiikkaa, myös oppilaitaan, joista on tullut asiakkaita. Lehdet ovat luopuneet vanhanaikaisesta valistajan roolista ja kyselevät yleisöltä, mikä on tärkeää. Nettiäänestyksissä media tenttaa lukijan mielipidettä asioihin, jotka eivät ole mielipiteestä kiinni: tuliko lama, lämpeneekö ilmasto, tappavatko rokotteet, mitä mieltä jengi.
Asiakkaan rooli voi imarrella meitä hetken, mutta demokratian ja sivistyksen osalta se on tylsä loukku: olemme aina oikeassa, ja siksi meidän ei tarvitse omaksua uutta.
My approximate translation:
When we have repeated for many years that the people (here meant as the audience) know best all the cultural institutions have begun to agree. Universities are assumed to serve both business and politics but also the students who are now customers. Newspapers have given up their old-fashioned role as educators and enlighteners. Instead, they ask the public what is important. In online polls the media wants the reader's opinions on matters which are not based on opinions: did we have an economic recession, is the climate warming, do vaccinations kill. What do you guys think?
The role of a customer can momentarily flatter, but it's a boring trap from the point of view of democracy and culture: we are always right and that's why we don't have to learn anything new.
What To Read Today on Gender, 4/16/15
1. This article about feminist foreign policy is worthwhile. A quote:
Last month, Saudi Arabia abruptly cut ties with Sweden, recalling its ambassador and announcing that it would issue no new visas to Swedish business travelers. The cause, according to Saudi Arabia, was some remarks made by Margot Wallström, the foreign minister of Sweden.
...
On February 11th, Wallström, speaking before the Swedish parliament, stated what may appear to be a few facts about Saudi Arabia: she said that women are not allowed to drive, that their human rights are violated, and that the country is a dictatorship in which the royal family has absolute power. Like representatives of several other European countries, she also criticized the public flogging of the blogger Raif Badawi and later called it “medieval.”
Wallström, whose government recognized the State of Palestine last year, had been asked to deliver a speech at an Arab League summit in Cairo in late March, but Saudi Arabia intervened, and Wallström was disinvited. On March 9th, Saudi Arabia withdrew its ambassador to Sweden, saying that Wallström had “unacceptably interfered” in the country’s internal affairs. The United Arab Emirates followed suit a week later. Due to Saudi Arabia’s diplomatic wrangling, Wallström was also condemned by the Gulf Cooperation Council (which consists of Bahrain, Oman, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, and the U.A.E.), The Organization of Islamic Cooperation, which includes fifty-seven countries, and the Arab League itself. Finally, Saudi Arabia leveled a more serious charge against Wallström: that by commenting on the punishment of public flogging, the Swedish foreign minister had criticized Sharia law and Islam.
There are similar pressures in writing. How does one criticize beliefs and not people? And are other people allowed to tell us not to criticize their beliefs? Should Western feminists be silent about ISIS, because criticizing ISIS so easily is viewed as criticizing Islam, given the discrimination and labeling of Muslims, especially in the West?
But if Western feminists are silent about ISIS, what remains of feminism? How can a feminist write about the forced-birth policies of US conservatives and not write about this?
I'm on Wallström's side in this, and that's why I worry about the argument that her comments are somehow the same as criticizing Sharia law (which is deemed to have a divine origin).
2. Female chimpanzees are more likely than male chimpanzees to fashion weapons and use them in hunting, according to one study. I have not read the study, but note the framing, especially in the last paragraph. Then check how often this particular study is disseminated, compared to the earlier study about how female chimpanzees appeared to shape branches into dolls. That one was widely disseminated and discussed, along the lines that "we all know the gender roles in humans are innate. Just look at the chimps!"
I bet this one won't get the same amount of publicity, because it doesn't serve to prop up human gender roles. As Terry Pratchett states in one of his books, people don't want news, they want "olds:" reinforcement for what they already believe to be true.
In any case, I've written about the gender politics in this field earlier.
3. Martha MacCallum really really dislikes the idea of a woman's head on US paper money. There's a movement to get a woman on the twenty-dollar bill, and Bill O'Reilly and Martha MacCallum ruminated on that at Fox News. O'Reilly asked why everything must be so damn politically correct*, and MacCallum disliked the idea that this movement is all about women. It would be more interesting, I guess, if it was about melons or papayas.
Sigh. The movement wouldn't have to be all about women if the US had had the same number of male and female presidents and if the Founding Fathers had been joined with some Founding Mothers, dear Martha. Context matters.
MacCallum stated that for her the heads on money are US presidents and a few Founding Fathers, and that statement creates an infinite loop with my previous paragraph. Or put Abigail Adams on the money.
4. As many people say on Twitter: "I can't even..." That's the term describing utter exhaustion with the silliness that goes on in American politics. Now that Hillary Clinton has stepped into the ring we are going to have several years hilarious sexism. And I have this feeling I should write about it.
Perhaps I will, perhaps I won't, but I can't help lifting up the skirt on the particular commentary of a Texas marketing CEO Cheryl Rios, who believes that women are too hormonal to run a country (even though apparently not too hormonal to run a marketing firm) and that this is why we shouldn't have a female president. Imagine her hand on the switch which rules nuclear weapons! She might start a poorly thought-out war! Gasp! And gasp!
Enough exclamation marks for you? In any case, Hillary Clinton probably has calmer hormones, given her post-menopausal stage, than any of the younger guys joining the race. And quite possibly calmer hormones than the older guys, at least based on what I've observed of her in the public eye over the years.
But if that isn't enough to convince you not to vote for Hitlery** (a conservative pet-name for Clinton), there's also the Biblical argument which is very very logical Rios tells us. (I've read the Bible and can't recall where the logic in the statements are. They just tell us that men should rule over women and that women should shut up.) And if even that won't make you face the facts, well, what will all those sexist countries think of the US if it is run by a woman? How can we possibly invade them or start reckless wars against them if they won't even respect us because of our gender equality policies?
OK. That last bit was me pretending to be inside the head of Cheryl Rios. I got all dizzy and hormonal.
----
* That term is a euphemism for "let's ignore large classes of people" in politics and in business. It's also shorthand for "here comes the bit where we dis women and/or minorities." It's a marvelous term! And a boring one, because it doesn't say WHY the utterer finds something politically correct but in reality completely false and unnecessary and trivial. It's right-wing code-speak.
** This post is not about Hillary Clinton as a candidate. Voters have their own reasons for voting or not voting for a particular candidate. My focus here (and in the future) is in the kind of statements which are not about Clinton at all but about all women or all women of a particular age etc.. In other words, about sexism and misogyny and the use of extreme stereotypes based on gender.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



