Thursday, July 03, 2014

A Substantial Burden: To Fill In A Form


In the most recent Supreme Court round concerning the coverage of contraception in employer-linked health insurance policies, we learn that what is a "substantial burden" is completely determined by the firms who don't wish to cover birth control.  This is the Wheaton College case.  Wheaton College argues that filling in a form telling others that they will not provide birth control coverage is too impossible a burden, and the majority  of the SCOTUS (the five Catholic guys) agreed!

In the"blistering" dissent by the three female Justices Sotomayor points out that when the recent decisions are taken together we end up in a trap of impossibility:

In fact, that accommodation was one of the reasons Justice Samuel Alito cited to justify his Hobby Lobby decision – words Sotomayor threw back at him in the dissent. Under the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, the government has to show it has pursued the least restrictive means to accomplish its goal. Alito claimed that because the nonprofit accommodation exists, that means the government has other ways to get women access to contraception that respects religious liberty. Yet only a few days later, he ruled that the nonprofit accommodation – again, signing a form – is also a violation of religious liberty.
“Let me be absolutely clear: I do not doubt that Wheaton genuinely believes that signing the self-certification form is contrary to its religious beliefs,” Sotomayor wrote. “But thinking one’s religious beliefs are substantially burdened … does not make it so.” She added, “Not every sincerely felt ‘burden’ is a ‘substantial’ one, and it is for courts, not litigants, to identify which are.” 
What the plaintiffs in the nonprofit cases are seeking is to be treated like churches – no contraception for anyone. But the majority claims that “nothing in this interim order affects the ability of the applicant’s employees and students to obtain, without cost, the full range of FDA approved contraceptives,” because the government already knows about their objection from the lawsuit and can tell the insurer itself. But without the form, Sotomayor argues, how could the administration “ever identify the organizations eligible for the accommodation and perform the administrative tasks necessary to make the accommodation work?” 

What's a "substantial burden" in an abortion case, say?  Nothing much:



On the other hand, filling in a form is a substantial burden for religiously minded entities.

What the Supreme Court majority has accomplished here is pure politics.  I thought activist judges were something the American right didn't want on the bench?  These five guys have just created the most self-contradictory story possible:



So now we know that nothing the Five Catholic Guys says can be relied upon when it comes to future legal decisions.  The Hobby Lobby case was narrowly-tailored?   Riiiiight.


Wednesday, July 02, 2014

Opening the Pandora's Box: What the Hobby Lobby Decision Might Achieve


A world in which things like gender discrimination are AOK for religious firms?  Here are some thoughts in that direction:
Companies that exist primarily for religious reasons might theoretically object to providing counseling programs for alcoholics, or insurance coverage for women if they object to women working outside the home, says Keith McMurdy, a partner in the New York City-based law firm Fox Rothschild.

Steven Friedman, an attorney in the New York City office of Littler Mendelson, foresees many religious-based challenges from private companies. “In a way, the sky is the limit because there are a lot of religious beliefs out there that don’t comport with the requirements of U.S. law.”

Perhaps none of this would happen.  But it's hard to guess how someone like Samuel Alito would rule on a case which pits, say, women's rights to fair treatment in the labor market against the religious rights of a firm which believes that women shouldn't be in the labor market at all.  Or any other kind of case where a religous firm's beliefs are in direct conflict with laws of this country.

I'm drawn here between two interpretations.  Either the five conservative men of the SCOTUS didn't think this through or they thought it through and this is what they wish to see.   Because they are not stupid men I veer towards the second interpretation. 

But given that "religion" doesn't mean just Christianity or Catholicism, the conservatives so happy about this ruling might regret it later when representatives of other religions start bringing cases to courts.  My impression is that American conservatives aren't terribly keen to have the principles of Sharia operate here.  Or Wiccan beliefs.

Let's hope that my concerns are exaggerated.  The hot and humid weather...

Tuesday, July 01, 2014

How The Scales Fell Off My Eyes: More on Hobby Lobby As Really Bad Law Interpretation


Remember yesterday?  How Justice Alito told us that a for-profit firm, held in the close embrace of its owners though having 23,000 workers, can have true religious qualms about a sincerely held belief that certain contraceptives kill egg-Americans inside the wombs of women?  And that this belief should be respected, even if it is not based on science, for who is Alito to judge which fervently held religious beliefs should be allowed and which should not?  Though he does suggest that a fervently believed anti-vaccination or anti-blood-transfusion belief would not be allowed!

I found that a bit illogical but never mind.  I read all of Alito's arguments and even looked up some of the things he references, to try to understand where he relies on case law, presumably important in the US legal system.  I didn't find his chain of arguments that convincing (Ginsburg did that part much better in her dissent), but I admired Alito's ability to cleverly turn a particular ideological and religious position into something much wider.  Though of course that width is almost completely in reference to how it reduces the personhood of American women (and ultimately all American workers) while increasing the pious personhood of for-profit companies of almost any size, as long as their owners are not too many.

Still.  Stupid perennially-innocent me took him at face value:  That this was about a particular religious belief, having to do with forced-birthers and their ilk.  But today we find that any for-profit firm which somehow can be defined as closely held (definition left open) can refuse to cover all contraceptives in the health insurance it offers its workers!  Even those which nobody has ever argued to have anything to do with aborting fertilized eggs.

That would be firms owned by Catholics, initially.  Given that all the five Justices in the majority are Catholic men, the whole thing reeks.  Now I'm sitting and waiting for the first Sharia case coming to courts.  For instance, someone could argue that female workers should be segregated from male workers and that the former should be veiled.  Clearly it no longer matters if those workers have the same religion as the firm's owners.  That's what I mean by the increased personhood of firms and the diminished personhood of workers.  Note, also, how Alito's definition of religious rights splashes over everyone else's human rights.  Those who don't have the same religions must nevertheless go along with it.

Because all the large Abrahamic religions codify the second-class status of women, an increase in religious rights is very likely to run smack into reduced rights for women.  I get that other laws might used to deny firms the rights to discriminate, but Alito only specifies race-based discrimination as not allowable under his new corporate religion scheme.  That leaves open the possibility that Lesbians and gays and all heterosexual women could suffer from other people's religious rights and that the Supreme Court would side with the religions.


Monday, June 30, 2014

And In Case We Forget This About the Hobby Lobby Case


 Employer-provided health insurance is not some gift from benevolent feudal lords and ladies but part of the worker's overall salary/wages plus benefits package.  When someone accepts an employment offer, that "someone" regards the whole compensation package as compensation.
 
I would much prefer that health insurance be detached from employment altogether, but if that cannot be achieved we should not let ourselves be driven into a situation where someone else is expected to subsidize those salaries or wages because of religious scruples by the said feudal lords and ladies.

Meet Hobby Lobby, A Corporate Person with Religious Rights


Samuel Alito, a Justice in the Supreme Court of the United States handed American corporations nicely wrapped gifts this morning!  One decision makes unionizing a little bit harder in the public sector.  The less countervailing power workers have the better the life for the employers:  Wages and benefits will stay lower and that's good for the profit motive!
 
Another decision, the Hobby Lobby one, states that a for-profit firm is a person with religious rights, as long as it is a closely held corporation.  Some ninety percent of corporations are closely held.  Hobby Lobby has 23,000 employees and 578 stores, but it is still closely held. 

Alito argues in the majority opinion of the Court that Hobby Lobby is a mere extension of the Christian religious beliefs the owning family holds, and those beliefs include the assumption that certain contraceptives are not contraceptives at all but cause abortions.  Therefore, all the 578 Hobby Lobby stores hold those same beliefs (whether science-based or not), and all the 578 Hobby Lobby stores are allowed to be exempt from the Affordable Care Act requirement that women's contraceptive needs should be covered without out-of-pocket costs.  That's a mighty big person.

Alito bases this on an expansion of religious rights to for-profit firms and the suggestion that the female employees of Hobby Lobby could be offered contraceptive coverage through some other means and not through the firm's health insurance policies.

Here's the part of the majority (the five Conservatives of the Court) opinion which made my teeth hurt:

In any event, our decision in these cases is concerned solely with the contraceptive mandate. Our decision should not be understood to hold that an insurance- mandate must necessarily fall if it conflicts with an employer’s religious beliefs.  Other coverage requirements, such as immunizations, may be supported by different interests (for example, the need to combat the spread of infectious diseases) and may involve different arguments about the least restrictive means of providing them.

A narrowly tailored SCOTUS decision?  So narrowly tailored that only women fit into it?  I'm not a lawyer, but this looks odd to me.  Is Alito saying that this case cannot ever be used as a precedent for anything else?  That lack of access to contraception has no societal effects of the kind refusal to vaccinate might have?  That contraceptives are never used for the treatment of medical illnesses?

The dissent by Ruth Bader Ginsburg is well worth reading, despite its length (or check out the summaries here and here).  She addresses the use of contraceptives for medical illnesses, the radical expansion of religious rights to for-profit corporations and she points out the health value of avoiding unplanned pregnancies.  She also discusses the important differences between for-profit companies, even family owned ones, and religious non-profits.

Then there's the fact that this "narrowly tailored decision" was about beliefs having to do with what might be taking place in those hidden uteri, and the equally astonishing fact that none of the five Justices in the majority happen to have uteri.  On the other hand, they all share the same religion with strong views against contraception.  Those views may not have mattered among the reasons for the decision, but it's hard for me to understand why contraception is singled out from all possible religious opposition to generally prevailing laws of the country.






  







 


Friday, June 27, 2014

Cynical Political Humor for Today


1.  On the question of how the US is to determine which parts of the Syrian opposition it should arm and abet, a possible list of questions is presented here.  What on earth could possibly go wrong by choosing to ship more arms into a particular battle zone?  Come to think of it, we should send a lot of drones, because they can be reused to bomb quite different parts of the globe.

2.  Here's an example of a lovely person who runs an alternative pregnancy center for Fallen Women and what she believes about women and contraception:

There is a war on women, but we’re not waging it,” Pinto added. “It’s coming from the pit of hell, like it did in the book of Genesis, when he told the women — when she bit the apple, he said, ‘You will not die.’”
“It’s the same lie. It’s the same war. And it’s not just on women, it’s on humanity. It’s on every aborted baby girl and baby boy. And every woman, and every man that has impregnated her.”

Don't you just love that term "impregnated, especially when expanded to every woman having been impregnated by every man?"  Then there's the reference to the original sin of being born female.  We should all try to avoid that, if at all possible. 

Elsewhere she calls the women who attend her center human wreckage.  Remember, SHE is the alternative the forced-birth right offers women.  So sweet.

3.  Dunlop suggested these golf tees as a good Father's Day gift.  They are shaped like headless naked pink women.  You put the golf ball where the head should be and then you whack off!  It's clearly something every dad fervently wants to own.  If nothing else, it's a good topic for discussion:  You hate all the bitches, too?  No? Really?  I thought everyone does.  Why would Dunlop sell these things otherwise?

4.  This piece is about the danger of pitchforks.  It's a semi-comical essay on one of the risks of being  super-rich when wealth and income inequality increases.





Thursday, June 26, 2014

Connect The Dots: Matt Lauer Interviews General Motors CEO Mary Barra. Morocco Prime Minister Bemoans Working Women.


The horrors of employed mothers!

In Morocco,  Prime Minister Abdelilah Benkirane has spoken about the deep disaster that working women have caused in his country.  He compares women safely inside the home to lanterns or chandeliers. If the lantern walks out of the home, the home will be in darkness.

He then continues:
...by complaining that the “sacred status God gave” to mothers who stay at home was being disrespected. “We will continue to defend our position against this modernity that is trying to eliminate family in our lives by reversing the roles of men and women,” he said.

There's an "I'm-Not-A-Chandelier" response to his comments in the social media.

So it goes.  What I like about Benkirane's statement is the open admission that he fears a role reversal.  How horrible it would be to have him viewed as a chandelier!  How horrible it would be if he wasn't allowed to go out or participate in politics!

I planned to write about his views as one stage in the process of greater gender equality, perhaps comparing it to the fears some Americans had that the suffrage of women would result in apron-clad-men having to stay at home and care for the children while the women went out, dressed for business and smoking cigars.  That was based on an old anti-suffrage poster.

Luckily, I didn't have to go quite that far back in the US history, because we heard from Matt Lauer so very recently.  His interview with the CEO of General Motors Mary Barra contained several daring questions about the true meaning of womanhood and motherhood:

Wednesday, June 25, 2014

Conservative Writers on Campus Rape


Remember that George Will column about the coveted nature of being a victim of a sexual assault on US college campuses?  I wrote about it earlier.  The column brought poor George some trouble, partly because of the illogical and furious voices on the net.  Or so he thinks.  The St. Louis Post-Dispatch also dropped his column after the controversy.

What's so terrible about suggesting that being raped is a coveted status, Will appears to ask us.  It's a legitimate intellectual position to take, to argue that sexual assaults can be just bad sex, bad choices by the victim. 

Perhaps he should ask that question of those victims or survivors who spend years, decades even, in therapy, who try to bind together the frayed bits of their lives, who desperately try to trust people again, who strive for healthy sexuality and fail, over and over again.  Who are afraid to go out, for instance.  Those sufferers are not all women, either.

My apologies for that paragraph.  Will's column didn't have paragraphs of that sort, and their absence was part of the problem.  If you are going to write about the "nonexistent" sexual assaults, also write about the "existent" ones,  unless you are willing to hear from the sufferers of those, to correct your oversight.

This whole topic lures odd stuff out of the woodwork.  For instance, this one:

A George Will column about sexual assault, which received lots of criticism and caused one newspaper to drop the longtime syndicated conservative columnist, had all male editors, the Washington Post's Erik Wemple reported on Friday.
“On that day, there were three males, if that is important to you,” Alan Shearer, CEO and editorial director of Washington Post News Media Services, which is the company that syndicates Will's columns, told Wemple in response to a question about whether any women had reviewed the column.
Is it important to you?  And if it is, what do we learn from that?  I'm not sure.  Are we to assume that male editors couldn't identify with being a victim of a sexual assault but would identify with, say, being falsely accused of one when sex turns out less than wonderful? 

What are the statistical odds of a man being either the victim of a sexual assault or of being falsely accused of one?  My guess is that the former group is larger than the latter group, but a group of three editors would be unlikely to have anyone from either group, given the overall statistics. So are we to think that men, as a class, cannot identify with the victims of sexual assaults but women, as a class, can?

That may be the case.   When I call these arguments odd I don't mean that they wouldn't have actual content or that they wouldn't be worth investigating.  At the same time, there's a sense of war fronts being set up in a certain way, with conservative writers worrying about the rights of college students who are accused of sexual assault to due process and liberal or progressive writers worrying about the same rights for college students who allege that they are raped or sexually assaulted.  If you omit gender references, that's what you get.

But you can't really omit gender in this conversation.  The conservative writers quickly fall back to "innate" positions where the women are supposed to be the gate-keepers, where they are supposed to be modest and to cross their legs, where they are not supposed to get inebriated, and where nobody explicitly negotiates sex, unless it's for money. 

None of that has saved India from a wave of publicized gang rapes or killings, by the way, and neither has the idea of "implicit consent" worked anywhere where "consent" can be interpreted as being out in the streets without a chaperone or having a short skirt or whatever other cultural rules are being used to define "consent" from one extreme angle.

Is there anything at all useful in these conservative writings about sexual assault?  Perhaps what I have revealed above?  That the debate is about where to draw the line which defines that we have moved from sex to sexual assault, and that different people have very different ideas about where that line should be drawn.  Remember the legitimate rape arguments?

Still, it would be a great idea to create a short question which everyone can use about sex, a question which isn't too clinical or too weird, one which can be answered in the affirmative by anyone who wants to have sex with the one popping the question, with full understanding of what it is one has agreed to.  We don't have that in our cultures, and we need that.



 






Monday, June 23, 2014

Anna Katherine Green. The Mother of the American Detective Novel.


She wasn't the father of the American detective novel, but her first novel, the Leavenworth Case (1878), was one of the first detective novels ever written*.  One site describes the book's  importance as follows:

That device has, of course, been used time and time again in mysteries, and for this and other reasons, it is sometimes tempting to fault The Leavenworth Case as a clichéd work…until one realizes that this is the book that established the situations and lines that would later become clichés (for instance, when asked whom he suspects of the murder, Gryce cryptically replies: “Every one and nobody”).

Arthur Conan Doyle and Wilkie Collins admired her work, and Agatha Christie specifically mentioned her as a role model.

I'm writing about her because I read quite a bit of her work over the weekend.  Her style is Victorian florid, with upper class young women depicted as virginal frail flowers, wilting in the wind, petals dropping off if the woman forgets to wear a hat and so on.  It may be that writing style which has kept Green in the shadows**.  And the books I read have plenty of the kind of sexism and classism etc. which grates on the modern reader.

But Green was born in 1846, and for a woman to write in those days she  had to write the way Green did, at least in the sense that the female characters had to comply with the then-common gender norms.  A lot of fainting, a lot of trembling, and those would excuse her clever plot schemes.  She can also create realistic characters when her pen describes older men or older women or charladies and others of lower class.  Then she is both funny and perspicacious.

I wasn't familiar with Green's writings before.  Perhaps you are, if you like detective novels.  But it was pretty exciting to meet and spot the prototypes of Miss Marple, the basic plot of the Pale Horse and several other plot devices later writers have used.  As that first quote pointed out, her work seems full of cliches until you realize that she created many of the ideas which now look old hat to us.

Why was I excited about all that?  Because it's always nice to find how the magic trick was done, where, say, Agatha Christie and others got their basic ideas and how they built on those, and because it's nice to slot some of the missing puzzle pieces into the history of the detective novel.  Anna Katherine Green certainly belongs there and is a major piece in the overall puzzle.



-----
*She probably wasn't the very first woman to publish a detective novel in the US, so in that sense she wasn't the mother, either.  Stepmother?
**On the other hand, the fainting and trembling women are not exactly uncommon in the books written by Victorian men and neither is the florid language.

Fairness And Other Nonsense in the Gospels


I don't think Erick Erickson is a Viking, despite the name.  He's a conservative pundit who recently wrote about Christianity and the "gay mafia" (his term), the point being that Erick's  god will smite (smite!) gays and lesbians and orders true believers to disapprove of same-sex love.  That particular god also approves of the stoning of adulterers and otherwise matches the ancient models of the gods of thunder. 

Because humans interpret and define divinity on the basis of their own understanding, warlike cultures get war gods and so on.  The views of divinity change over time.  That's why the god in the Bible appears to have multiple personalities.  Only some of those, for example, want to oppress women a lot.  Jesus doesn't have much to say about the importance of keeping women down or about the perfidy of gayness.



Which brings me to the quote from Erick, the son of Erick, which I find most illuminating:

When preachers give up that prophetical role and focus only on the pastoral, we get people claiming the gospel is about fairness and other nonsense.
I'm for fairness and other nonsense myself.  But it's certainly true that any religion with staying power will be fuzzy and muddled enough (and even more so after a lot of interpretations) that almost anyone can find something in it to match their desires about how the divinity should be.  Thus we get the smiting god, the god who drinks blood, the god who chases the traders out of the temple, the god who defends the prostitute, the jealous god, the grieving god, the loving god, even the fairness-and-other-nonsense god.

And if your particular variety isn't catered for, you can always start a new sect.  For instance, one which tells that rich people are rich because god wants them to be rich, or one which tells you that you can have as many wives as you wish.

Religions also have wonderful aspects, great messages and the ability to help those who suffer.  At the same time, humans interpret presumed divine words (or their ideas of those) pretty poorly, on the whole.  We are very clever at stressing the bits we like and ignoring the bits we don't like.  Those who support literal readings of holy books are not much bothered by the fact that they talk about aspects of cultures which existed centuries ago and sometimes refer to very specific historic events or by the fact that literal readings are ultimately not feasible, because of both the internal inconsistencies they create and because of the problems of interpreting the meanings of ancient languages today.

What are you going to nail your view of life to?  That might be the ultimate question which religions try to answer, but as the case of Erick Erickson demonstrates, the answer depends on the wielder of the hammer.




Friday, June 20, 2014

Thursday, June 19, 2014

Speed-Blogging 6/19/14: Straw-Feminism, American Apparel, Scott Walker Etc.


Short posts, because I didn't get enough sleep for long posts.   Here they are:



Straw-feminism on Twitter:  Anti-feminist trolls pretending to be feminists create hashtags such as these last week:
Anonymous image board 4chan has a section called /pol/. Sometime around Thursday or Friday of last week, users on /pol/ decided to try and get the hashtag #EndFathersDay trending on Twitter. Users at the time compared it to similar fake activism tags like #WhitesCantBeRaped, which, as a quick search on Twitter reveals, appears to have been a failed prank attempted last week.
More about this form of trolling  here.   I have no idea what motivate these particular examples of trolling, though I'm pretty sure that misogynists would participate eagerly.  Others might just like to break things or stir the pot because pranks make them feel powerful.

Speaking of trolls, the founder of American Apparel, Dov Charney, is the reason behind the porn approach the firm uses in advertising of women's clothes. I've wondered about those ads, because the intended buyers are women.  Are women to be self-sexual?  Aroused by what Dov is aroused by?  Who knows.

In Japan, something a bit sexist happened in politics.  That's not uncommon in several countries, by the way, the United Kingdom being famous for sexist gestures in the House of Commons when female members give speeches.  Men describe boob shapes in air and so on.

What's interesting about the UK use of political aggression is that it's not about what is being said but about who is saying it, and the desired results are probably silent or (even better!) absent women in the corridors of power.  It's that generalizing aspect of the aggression which makes it something to write about.

Finally, there are rumors about possible trouble for Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker.   Those who have read me before know that I see him as a Ringwraith from Tolkien's Lord of the Ring, obeying blindly the commands of a central conservative think tank.  Some background for the case can be found here, and the most recent take here.  This is a general article about the history of Walker's climb to power and how it relates to race.



  



Wednesday, June 18, 2014

Today's Research Granola: On Beefy Facial Features, Women's Odds of Becoming Principal Investigators in STEM Fields Etc.


1.  Here's a fun study summary for you about the reason why our male ancestors had such very strong jaws that nobody ever would have wanted to hit them in the jaw while, say, boxing:
A new theory suggests that our male ancestors evolved beefy facial features as a defence against fist fights.
The bones most commonly broken in human punch-ups also gained the most strength in early "hominin" evolution.
They are also the bones that show most divergence between males and females.
Don't worry about that seeming illogicality of both arguing that beefy facial features evolved as a defense against fist fights AND that the bones most commonly broken in human punch-ups are those same strengthened ones.  This is because the argument is not about today's humans but about early hominins.  Human males today no longer have that "protective buttressing," at least to the same extent.  According to the study authors, this is because it's no longer needed, probably because fist fights are something from ancient history.

I have nothing against their hypothesis, except that it's impossible to test.  For example, we have no way of knowing if ancient hominins engaged in fist fights or if they fought by using some other tools.  But I really wonder about this argument:


Monday, June 16, 2014

Today's Deep Echidne Thoughts: Inadvertent Meat-Eating, Tribalism And Window-Washing


And not so deep ones.

First, if a mosquito commits suicide in my cold coffee by this computer and I drink the coffee (because I like cold coffee but not ice coffee so I let it go cold), am I no longer a vegetarian?  How can I atone?  ---  Asking theoretically, of course.

Second, what can we do about tribalism?  The soccer games a lot of you are watching are about tribalism, the US gundamentalist ammosexual movement* is about tribalism, what is happening in the death fields of the Middle East is also largely about tribalism.  About who is in "our" group and who is not.

Tribalism in sports is much preferable to tribalism in the killing fields, naturally.  The UN should encourage it.  Indeed, we should bring back gladiator fights**, but only between the heads of the states and runners for those posts.

As an alternative to wars, that is.  And yes, I know it wouldn't work***, but the idea is a good one in theory.  We could allow modern weapons to make the fights equal for people of different sizes, ages and genders.  The outcome could only be protested as a prelude to a second match, between, say, the seconds-in-command.  The fight would never leak down to the general populations.

Third, window-washing.   This is a deep thought topic only because I have been doing it.  Imagine nearly hundred-year old windows, with that up-and-down guillotine movement.  Imagine having to wash them on the outside from a long distance from the ground, dangling half outside.

Imagine an intrepid goddess armed with a mallet and chisels (for opening recalcitrant antique windows),  bottles of window-washing liquid and rags, part of her clinging to the frame of the house, her mouth holding the rags (for lack of more arms (one is needed to hold on to the house for dear life) and a prehensile tail).  Imagine how all that looks and how it feels when the top frame decides to drop on the neck of the said goddess.

Well, I won, this last weekend.  But the victory is always temporary, as it may be in politics, too.  And that should bring you an odd kind of optimism when things are going very badly on the international front.
----------
*These terms refer to second amendment fanatics.  I don't know who invented them but they are pretty clever slurs.
**Like John McCain in one corner, armed with hammers, John Kerry in the other corner, armed with French after-shave.  To make an example from the past.  So to say.
***It wouldn't work, because the minute we invented this scheme all countries would pick someone very brawny and violent and without relatives as the nominal head of the state.  Real strings of power would be held by the Usual Suspects.



Friday, June 13, 2014

Goldman Sachs CEO on Income Inequality


Worth checking out what Lloyd Blankfein, the CEO of Goldman Sachs says about the growing income inequality:

Income inequality is destabilizing and "responsible for the divisions in the country," CEO and chairman of Goldman Sachs Lloyd Blankfein said on "CBS This Morning" Tuesday.
"The divisions could get wider," Blankfein said. "If you can't legislate, you can't deal with problems. [If] you can't deal with problems, you can't drive growth and you can't drive the success of the country. It's a very big issue and something that has to be dealt with."
He said one way to deal with it would be to "make the pie grow."
"Too much of the GDP over the last generation has gone to too few of the people," he said.

He also hints at the need to look at how the pie is divided, by the way.  Because the pie has been growing; it's just that it has been eaten by fewer people.  So the growth policy isn't really working, right?

The story goes on explaining how hard it is to figure out the reasons for the growing income inequality.  Though I respectfully want to point out that several of the reasons are quite easily determined, because they are the consequences of specific policies:  Increase the regression of income taxes, favor capital over labor in who pays the most taxes,  encourage the off-shoring of good jobs, do your utmost to tear up all safety nets (which the rich don't need, duh).

Blankfein's reference to politics is that "if you can't legislate" comment.  But the problem of American politics is that they are money-driven, that they are beginning to mirror the needs and desires of the one percent and become less and less reflective of the more general needs or desires.

Indeed, the same appears to be true on international level, too.  Trade policies are often crafted to comply with the interests of corporations, not with the interests of workers or consumers.


Thursday, June 12, 2014

Thank You


For your kind donations and for reading here.  I now have enough for a new computer, with an ergonomic keyboard and a large screen!   Big hugs and mwah.

The negative side is that I won't put myself out to pasture as early as I planned. 


Women Are Hard To Animate. Thoughts on Representation of Women in Movies, Television and Games


That "women are hard to animate" comes from today's Funny Files.  The excuse for not having female characters in the next game of a series called Assassin's Creed is that to have them would have doubled the workload of the animators.

That's polite shorthand for meaning that the customers of the game are viewed as being mostly male, so having female characters just isn't cost-effective (well, except perhaps for the tit-value), but it's also a lot like the old "but then we need toilets for women" argument which was made when some colleges had to turn coed.

Others found that defense funny, too.  Still, there's something deeper I can dig for you in this quote:

“Assassin’s Creed: Unity,” which takes place during the French Revolution through the Napoleonic wars, is a four-player co-0p, explained by Amancio here. Players can customize their gear, but always see themselves as the main character, Arno Dorian.
“Because of that, the common denominator was Arno,” Amancio explained. “It’s not like we could cut our main character, so the only logical option, the only option we had, was to cut the female avatar.”
That "deeper" has to do with the initial focus.  If the focus is on a guy called Arno Dorian and his adventures during Napoleonic wars, well, it IS a bit hard to put female heroes into the story. A realistic portrayal of women would be as a few sisters, wives and mothers, as victims of rape and other war violence and as prostitutes, right?  From the guy point of view (which we all can assume, I believe).  We don't know a whole lot about how women "played" war in history.  You could add something about trying to steal enough potatoes between the army lines to stay alive without getting caught, perhaps, to make the game more realistic.

That wasn't very clear.  My point is that these stories are picked from a certain angle, an angle of traditionally male heroism, and even when that is not the case most of us are lulled into believing that a handful of women in a large list of participants is a mixed gender setting in a movie or television series.  Just think of the Noah's Ark (which also consisted of all white characters).  Probably a fifty-fifty distribution of men and women in some movie reads as a chick flick to many viewers.

One reason for all this is that we tend to see women portray womanhood in their roles, not play roles of individuals who have different temperaments, characters and so on.  That's why having a handful of women in a movie looks like inclusion, even if they all play the role "women," because that role might be subconsciously compared to the number of dentists or gamblers or whatever in the same movie, never mind that most of the rest of that list are played by men.

A similar thinking applies to roles played by people of color (so women of color get a double dose here).  The only solution I can see is to increase the numbers of those groups closer to their actual population proportions.  Once a certain critical coalition size has been reached in jobs, say, women (or any other less represented group) stop being seen as representatives of their group and start being seen as individuals.  We are getting there but we are not there yet.


ISIS


Isn't it sarcastic that the acronym ISIS (Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant) is also the name of an ancient Egyptian goddess?  Because the ISIS, this time, is certainly not about a revered goddess but about creating a modern Islamic caliphate, a country stretching from Syria to Iraq and beyond, where the role of women would not have anything to do with potential divinity.

Never mind.  Given the current violence and population displacement, those concerns are not the foremost.  Stopping the violence would be, if anyone in the whole world just could figure out a way to do that, either in Syria or in Iraq.  That doesn't seem feasible.

Then the recriminations.  It's certainly true that the American invasion (to punish Saudi suicide bombers in 911 the US had to attack an unrelated country,  Iraq, though it was really about oil)  precipitated the current situation.  For instance,

While not as big as what it had been prior to the 1991 Gulf War, Iraq's military under Saddam Hussein boasted an estimated 430,000 soldiers and another 400,000 personnel in paramilitary units and security services when U.S.-led troops invaded in spring 2003.
Still, the Iraqis proved no match for coalition forces.
After the military was overrun, it was dissolved -- along with Iraq's defense and information ministries -- by Paul Bremer, the top U.S. civilian administrator in Iraq.
That left hundreds of thousands of troops suddenly out of work. Those with ranks of colonel and above -- who knew the most about strategy, tactics and more -- were hit even harder, as they weren't entitled to severance packages and couldn't work for the new Iraqi government.
Then they had to go somewhere.
According to Fawaz Gerges, a professor at the London School of Economics and Political Science, "hundreds, if not thousands, of skilled officers of Saddam Hussein's ... joined ISIS."

This is an example, one of many, of the lack of proper thinking before and during the US invasion of Iraq.

It is also true that the state of Iraq was patched together by the British, once upon a time, and doesn't lend itself to be a natural state, and the West's constant thirst for oil and the associated colonial history has played a major role in preparing the ground for the current events.

But we shouldn't  assume that the area would be a peaceful Eden in the absence of any Western influence.  The current violence in Iraq has to do with the Sunnis and the Shias and the Kurds, and the current violence in Syria is also religiously motivated.  The ISIS group appears to support an extreme form of an Islamist state in Raqqa, Syria,  where Sharia laws are rigidly applied, in their original medieval forms, and so on.  At the same time, their tactics in Iraq rely more on the support of Sunnis and the unhappiness with the current Iraqi leadership, because that works out better in the Iraqi context:

In the Syrian city of Raqqa, their strict brand of Islamic law holds sway. Activists and residents say music has been banned, Christians have to pay an Islamic tax for protection and people are executed in the main square.
In the Iraqi city of Fallujah, however, residents say the group has so far taken a more moderate approach, choosing to overlook some practices it considers forbidden.
The makeup of its forces also varies to a degree. In Syria, foreigners play a larger role than in Iraq, where locals tend to dominate.
The group has been able to do this, in part, because of the simmering anger in Iraq’s Sunni minority community toward Shiite Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki. They accuse al-Maliki of treating them as second-class citizens.
None of what I write here is based on any kind of expertise.  These are my amateur thoughts.

I'm not sure how democracy is historically developed, but I fear it begins with at least some bloodshed, and far too many countries appear to exist at that stage right now.  That's my more optimistic interpretation of what might be happening.  The pessimistic one is about a world divided by money and religion and sinking ever deeper into absolutes which cannot be questioned.

Though ISIS is unlikely to be strong enough on its own to create a permanent Islamic emirate or caliphate.  Ironically, should it succeed in that the outcomes would be bad for its future residents. The extremist Islamic model is a very poor fit for modern needs of economic and social development.


Tuesday, June 10, 2014

You've Been Bradwilcoxed. Washington Post on How Women Can Stay Safe.


I'm singularly blessed by my warped sense of humor.  It lets me enjoy the most recent Washington Post opinion piece on women, after the George Will one (about being a victim of sexual violence as a coveted status), partly because it reminds me of this opinion piece in 2008, about us wimminfolk:


We Scream, We Swoon. How Dumb Can We Get?

Imagine something like that published in WaPo about any other large demographic groups!

Anyway, today's piece is quite wonderful.  It suggests that all men should get married and have children, because that way they stop being violent towards women!


How We Should Cover Mass Murders


Yesterday I began a post with this:

It might be time not to give any publicity for the killers in these mass shooting events, because of the copycat criminals and the very real possibility that what the killers want is posthumous fame or notoriety.

I didn't finish the post.  But it wouldn't have made any difference in terms of what is clearly taking place right now.  Journalists should seriously think about how to report on mass murders, to keep the focus on the victims, what was lost by their deaths, what good things they did while alive, how great the grief is for those left behind.  The perpetrator should not be the focus, if at all possible, and when it is not, the treatment should take care to avoid the type of coverage which copycat killers would wish to read about themselves.

Monday, June 09, 2014

Being A Victim: A Coveted Status. Or So Writes George Will.


George Will is a conservative writer whom Charlie Pierce once compared to a vinegar decanter.   That was funny because it is apt.  Now George has decided to write about the crisis of sexual violence on US college campuses.

Colleges and universities are being educated by Washington and are finding the experience excruciating. They are learning that when they say campus victimizations are ubiquitous (“micro-aggressions,” often not discernible to the untutored eye, are everywhere), and that when they make victimhood a coveted status that confers privileges, victims proliferate.

Bolds are mine.

Will's message is that there is no crisis, that "males" get unfairly accused, that "females" are encouraged to see pity f**ks or similar as rapes.  If you are not quite convinced, George Will also tells us (he will tell us!) that  progressives want trigger warnings on all university reading materials, too:

Now the codes are begetting the soft censorship of trigger warnings to swaddle students in a “safe,” “supportive,” “unthreatening” environment, intellectual comfort for the intellectually dormant.
It is salutary that academia, with its adversarial stance toward limited government and cultural common sense, is making itself ludicrous. Academia is learning that its attempts to create victim-free campuses — by making everyone hypersensitive, even delusional, about victimizations — brings increasing supervision by the regulatory state that progressivism celebrates.
Hmm.  Now I want marshmallows.   Then I want to stab them hard.

George commits three common not-so-nice crimes in his piece. 

First, he picks a story about sexual violence which is as marginal as possible (from his point of view).  By picking that story and ignoring all the other stories he manages to suggest that sexual violence on campuses is pretty much nonexistent, and if it does exist, it's due to "the ambiguities of the hookup culture, this cocktail of hormones, alcohol and the faux sophistication of today’s prolonged adolescence of especially privileged young adults."

Second, he picks something which indeed has happened but which is both uncommon and avidly debated among progressives as indicative of the coddling culture on all campuses:  the demand for trigger warnings in college courses.  By implying that all progressives are for such warnings Will is being dishonest, and by not actually studying how common such trigger warnings are in reality he is being sorta lazy. 

Third, he argues that "males" have been denied due process:

Then comes costly litigation against institutions that have denied due process to males they accuse of what society considers serious felonies.
This glides over the fact that many "females" argue that they have been denied due process or justice.

These are not viewed as real crimes because Will is writing an opinion piece, not reporting on the issues.  But crimes they are from my point of view, because they aim at distorting the way the readers would interpret the events after consuming his story.